French see turn of tide in Palestine
All Posts post a reply | post a new topic

AuthorTopic: French see turn of tide in Palestine
topic by
John Calvin
2/18/2002 (20:38)
 reply top
Turn of tide seen in Palestine

http://www.dawn.com/2002/02/18/top14.htm

By Paul Michaud

PARIS, Feb 17: French strategists privy to the war being waged between Israeli and Palestinian forces in the occupied territories, say the successful attack on Thursday on a Merkava 3 tank by an unusually powerful Palestinian explosive device constitutes a 'major turning point' in the war, and that a 'turn of the tide' could take place in the coming weeks, if not days.

The French analysts have indeed begun speaking in terms of a possible 'Hezbollization' of the war as for the first time in their memory, the Palestinian military appears to be employing the very methods heretofore associated with the Hezbollah in their war against the Israelis in Lebanon, methods that brought about the decision by Tsahal in May 2000 to withdraw from the security zone they had occupied until then in southern Lebanon.

The French strategists say the arrival of the unusually powerful new weapon - which was deployed by the military branch of the people's committees particularly active in the Gaza Strip in recent weeks - was so unexpected that according to their own intelligence, Israeli military planners were also caught unawares by the attack and 'began understanding the significance of what had happened' only this weekend.

The Israeli specialists, say the French, are shocked over the destruction of the 60-ton Merkava 3, as it was considered near-invincible - this in part because of its sophisticated electronic gear - indeed, it is viewed at least in other capitals like Washington as one of the most powerful tanks presently in use anywhere on the planet.

The French analysts also note that they, too, not only the Israeli defence planners, are quite surprised that the Palestinians were able to deploy an explosive device which in their estimation had an explosive force of at least 100kg, as it sent the 60-ton tank flying into the air and left an enormous crater, estimated to be over a metre deep and measure several metres in diameter.

A prototype of a new generation Israeli tank, Merkava 4, was to have come off the assembly line in the coming weeks, but now its arrival may be delayed, estimate the French analysts, as Israeli defence planners attempt to correct the tank's weak points in order to avoid further damage to the tank, which until now had been the pride and joy of Tsahal.

The explosion which killed three Israeli military personnel could also take its toll on Israeli public opinion - which until now has been largely supportive of Prime Minister Ariel Sharon's unlimited war on Palestine - but according to the French analysts, might be ready to consider more moderate solutions to the war if Sharon's war gets bogged down, which the French strategists say is what is beginning to happen.

Moreover, they note, Tsahal has been seriously embarrassed by the decision of several Israeli military reservists to refuse henceforth to serve in the occupied territories, claiming that their actions are serving no useful purpose, but being used solely to 'humiliate' the Palestinian people.

If there is a positive side to Israel's problems in the occupied territories, say the French strategists, it is that the apparent turning of the tide comes at a most appropriate moment, as France prepares to actively lobby for acceptance of the new peace plan recently presented to France's major allies by its principal architect, French Foreign Minister Hubert Vedrine.

The plan, as presented in late January by Vedrine, depends in large part on the holding of general elections in the Palestinian territories, as well as the declaration of a Palestinian state as early as possible, in any case before its geographical borders are determined.

Vedrine, in presenting the plan, noted that declaration of a Palestinian state 'should be a point, a departure, not necessarily the eventual goal of negotiations.' He said: 'Our plan will hopefully provoke a psychological shock, relaunch the peace process, indeed justify the end of the second Intifada.'

Although reaction to the plan has for the moment been quite lukewarm, say French specialists related to the matter, the possible 'Hezbollization' of the war in the occupied territories could very well 'catalyze' the peace process, precipitating the changes that have long been awaited, changes that could make Vedrine's propositions more appropriate and possible than ever - conditions that until now had not been reunited.

The French specialists note that one person who has given support to the plan is Yasser Arafat himself, who told a delegation of visiting lawmakers from Paris a week ago (last Sunday) that 'I appreciate all of the European initiatives towards peace, and the French plan in particular.'

Arafat may also have had an inkling of what was to come, notably with regard to the apparent change of Palestinian military strategy and the resulting Israeli Valentine's Day setback, as he told the French parliamentarians he hoped to be able to come to France in the near future to accept the invitations they had just made to him to address the French National Assembly in Paris and the European Parliament in Strasbourg. 'Now that I have not one, but two invitations, I'll just have to come,' Arafat is reported to have told one of the French parliamentarians.



reply by
John Calvin
2/18/2002 (20:40)
 reply top
Attacks take toll on Israeli confidence

Ben Lynfield in Jerusalem

http://www.thescotsman.co.uk/international.cfm?id=189192002

AMID seemingly relentless attacks, including a thwarted suicide bombing last night, many Israelis are losing confidence in the country’s ability to defeat the Palestinians.

Seven Israeli soldiers and civilians have died in the last week. As one of them, 15-year-old Nehemia Amar - killed on Saturday night by a suicide bomber after going for a pizza in the Karnei Shomron settlement in the West Bank - was laid to rest, reports quoted officials as saying Israel would escalate its army operations, which already include bombings of Palestinian cities with F-16 warplanes and tank incursions into territory nominally under Palestinian Authority control.

A 14-year-old girl, Keren Shatzki, also killed in the Karnei Shomron explosion, is to be buried today. The attack, the first suicide bombing inside a Jewish settlement, also wounded 20 people.

Responsibility for the bomb, which was packed with nails, was claimed by the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine in a further indication that secular groups are increasingly adopting the tactics of the fundamentalists.

'The state of Israel is losing the battle for the consciousness of its own citizens,' said Ron Ben-Ishai, a military affairs commentator for Israel Television. He pointed to a rally by peace activists on Saturday night that drew more than 10,000 people in Tel Aviv to demand an end to the occupation in the West Bank and Gaza Strip and a letter by more than 200 reserve officers refusing service in the occupied territories as signs that the public does not endorse the military effort.

'The impression is we don’t know where we are headed tactically and strategically,' Mr Ben-Ishai said. 'People don’t know why we are fighting.'

The bloody incidents began last month when Israeli troops assassinated a Palestinian militia leader, Ra’ed Karmi, putting an end to three weeks in which Palestinian violence had dropped off to its lowest level since the uprising began in September 2000.

Because the deaths trigger devastating revenge attacks, the assassinations policy is said to be under review among the Israeli cabinet, although a Hamas militant, Nabih Abu Sbaa, was killed on Saturday in the town of Jenin.

Police thwarted another suicide attack last night near the Israeli city of Hadera. They shot dead one assailant and mounted a car chase after the other, who blew himself up when he saw he could not get past a roadblock. Three people were wounded, two of them seriously, officials said.

Hours after the suicide bomber struck on Saturday night, Israeli aircraft hit the Palestinian city of Nablus, damaging Palestinian Authority installations and injuring one person in a block of flats.

There were conflicting reports on whether Israel had used F-16s, as it did three times in Gaza City last week, or only Apache assault helicopters.

Israeli troops invaded the Bureij refugee camp over the weekend and killed three Palestinian police after a Palestinian bombing nearby of a tank, in which three soldiers were killed. A fourth Palestinian policemen died in hospital yesterday. It was the first time the Palestinians had succeeded in destroying a tank.

Amid comparisons of that with the Iranian-inspired Hezbollah group’s successful campaign against Israeli forces in Lebanon, which was marked by roadside ambushes and explosions, a leading Israeli commentator, Ofer Shelah, wrote that the current situation is 'much worse' than anything Israel faced in Lebanon. 'For ten years just a couple of hundred Hezbollah fighters drove the army crazy. The number of Palestinians who have the potential to harm Israel is almost limitless.'

The prime minister, Ariel Sharon, said of the recent attacks and reversals: 'Israel has never lost a war and it will also be victorious in this war that the Palestinians launched. The residents of Israel have known more difficult times than today’s. Our standing together for the common objective will bring us to victory.'

The fighting was fuelled on 29 September, 2000, when five Palestinians were killed in clashes with Israeli police in Jerusalem after Mr Sharon visited a site holy to both Muslims and Jews in a move seen by Muslims as a provocation.