The Bird
Was Perfect But Not For Dinner
In Iraq Picture, Bush Is Holding the Centerpiece
By Mike
Allen
Washington
Post - December 4, 2003; Page A33 - President
Bush's Baghdad turkey was for looking, not for eating.
In the most widely published image from his Thanksgiving
day trip to Baghdad, the beaming president is wearing an Army workout
jacket and surrounded by soldiers as he cradles a huge platter laden
with a golden-brown turkey.
The bird is so perfect it looks as if it came from a
food magazine, with bunches of grapes and other trimmings completing a
Norman Rockwell image that evokes bounty and security in one of the
most dangerous parts of the world.
But as a small sign of the many ways the White House
maximized the impact of the 21/2-hour stop at the Baghdad airport,
administration officials said yesterday that Bush picked up a
decoration, not a serving plate.
Officials said they did not know the turkey would be
there or that Bush would pick it up. A contractor had roasted and
primped the turkey to adorn the buffet line, while the 600 soldiers
were served from cafeteria-style steam trays, the officials said. They
said the bird was not placed there in anticipation of Bush's stealthy
visit, and military sources said a trophy turkey is a standard feature
of holiday chow lines.
The scene, which lasted just a few seconds, was not
visible to a reporter who was there but was recorded by a pool
photographer and described by officials yesterday in response to
questions raised in Washington.
Bush's standing rose in a poll conducted immediately
after the trip. Administration officials said the presidential stop
provided a morale boost that troops in Iraq are still talking about,
and helped reassure Iraqis about U.S. intentions.
Nevertheless, the foray has opened new credibility
questions for a White House that has dealt with issues as small as who
placed the "Mission Accomplished" banner aboard the aircraft carrier
Bush used to proclaim the end of major combat operations in Iraq, and
as major as assertions about Saddam Hussein's arsenal of unconventional
weapons and his ability to threaten the United States.
The White House has updated its account of an airborne
conversation in which a British Airways pilot wondered into his radio
if he had just seen Air Force One and was told that it was a Gulfstream
5, a much smaller plane. White House officials first said that the
British Airways pilot had talked with the Air Force One pilot. Bush
aides now say the conversation occurred between the British Airways
pilot and an air traffic control worker.
"I don't think everybody was clear on exactly how that
conversation happened," White House press secretary Scott McClellan
said.
British Airways said it has been unable to confirm the
new version. "We've looked into it," a spokeswoman said from London.
"It didn't happen."
White House officials do not deny that they craft
elaborate events to showcase Bush, but they maintain that these events
are designed to accurately dramatize his policies and to convey
qualities about him that are real.
"This was effective, because it captured something about
the president that people know is true, that he really cares about the
soldiers and gets emotional when he sees them," Mary Matalin, a former
administration official, said about the trip to Baghdad. "You have to
figure out how to capture the Bush we know, even if it doesn't come
through in a speech situation or a press conference. He regularly
rejects anything that is not him."
The Democratic presidential candidates tipped their hats
to the White House stage managers by refusing to criticize the trip,
which dominated weekend newscasts.
Aides to the Democrats said they concluded that the less
said about the trip, the better. In the view of these aides, the trip
produced reassuring images of a situation that has badly deteriorated,
and Democrats just wanted the moment to pass so they could go back to
criticizing Bush's postwar policy.
A poll conducted four days after Thanksgiving by the
National Annenberg Election Survey put Bush's job approval rating at 61
percent, up from 56 percent during the four days before the holiday.
His job disapproval rating dropped from 41 percent to 36 percent. His
personal popularity increased from 65 percent to 72 percent. The polls
of 789 people before Thanksgiving and 847 people after Thanksgiving
each had a margin of error of plus or minus 3 percentage points.
The trip was pulled off in total secrecy -- only a few
Bush aides and reporters knew about it in advance, and they were
allowed to discuss it only on secure phone lines. Reporters covering
the Thanksgiving program in Baghdad were not allowed to report the
event until after Air Force One had left.
Some of the reporters left behind at Crawford Middle
School, where they work when Bush is staying at his Texas ranch, felt
they had been deceived by White House accounts of what Bush would be
doing on Thanksgiving.
Correspondent Mark Knoller said Sunday on "CBS Evening
News" that the misleading information and deception were
understandable, but that he had been "filing radio reports that
amounted to fiction."
"Even as President Bush was addressing U.S. personnel in
Baghdad, I was on the air saying he was at his ranch making holiday
phone calls to American troops overseas," Knoller said. "I got that
information from a White House official that very morning."